Sanibel Island Restaurants
The Timbers Restaurant & Fish Market
A Sanibel institution since 1978. The dining room's wood finishes and island-themed nautical decor set the mood. Alongside the fresh retail fish market, The Timbers is home to the Sanibel Grill — an energetic hub for seafood, sports, and spirits.
Restaurant Details
Plan Your Visit
Use the official restaurant website for current menus, reservations, and special events. Island hours can shift with the season.
What It's Known For
A longtime island institution since 1978, The Timbers blends a classic wood-and-nautical dining room with a respected on-site fish market. It's known for very fresh seafood, oyster-bar culture, and a more old-school Sanibel feel than many newer spots.
🍽️ Signature Dishes
Fresh oysters; local catch from the fish market
Best For
Seafood-focused dinners, regulars, and visitors who want a classic Sanibel restaurant rather than a trend-driven one.
🏝️ Local Tip
Check whether the raw bar or sushi/sashimi nights are running before you go; those have been especially popular with repeat visitors.
Hurricane Ian Recovery
Its sister Sanibel Grill reopened first after Ian, and The Timbers reopened in February 2023; open as of 2026.