Captiva Island Restaurants
Old Captiva House
Elegant fine dining at 'Tween Waters Island Resort on Captiva. Known for fresh seafood, steaks, and an extensive wine list in a historic setting.
Restaurant Details
Island
Captiva Island
Parent Venue
'Tween Waters
Phone
(239) 472-5161Hours
Nightly Dinner Service
Cuisine
Seafood
Price Range
$$$
Plan Your Visit
Use the official restaurant website for current menus, reservations, and special events. Island hours can shift with the season.
What It's Known For
Old Captiva House at 'Tween Waters is one of Captiva's more refined dining rooms, known for a historic setting, oceanfront location, and upscale 'New Florida' style menu. It feels more classic-resort dining than village-casual Captiva.
🍽️ Signature Dishes
Pomegranate-glazed lamb chops; lobster and crab-crusted scallops
Best For
Romantic dinners, resort guests, special occasions, and travelers who want a quieter, more elegant Captiva meal.
🏝️ Local Tip
Reserve ahead and lean into the seafood-forward entrees; this is a better pick for a slower, sit-down dinner than a quick casual stop.
Hurricane Ian Recovery
Reopened in re-envisioned form at 'Tween Waters after Hurricane Ian-related recovery and renovation work; operating as of 2026.