Explore Sanibel and Captiva restaurants for every kind of island dining, from fresh seafood and sunset views to casual cafés and longtime local favorites. Look for 🏝️ to spot the places locals keep coming back to.
Inside South Seas
Restricted access: eligible South Seas guests and owners with Club Captiva amenity access only; not general public dining. Gulf-inspired casual dining with panoramic sunset views at South Seas resort.
Inside The Bubble Room
Dessert-focused stop next to The Bubble Room, known for ice cream, baked treats, and café-style sweets.
Casual Mexican and Southwestern spot known for margaritas, tacos, and a lively island atmosphere.
Inside 'Tween Waters
Custom personal-pizza concept at 'Tween Waters featuring diverse fresh toppings and sauces.
Casual pizza spot in the village area focused on pies, delivery, and easy family takeout.
Inside 'Tween Waters
Upscale steakhouse at 'Tween Waters on Captiva. Premium steaks and seafood with island ambiance.
Inside South Seas
Restricted access: eligible South Seas guests and owners with Club Captiva amenity access only; not general public dining. Italian steakhouse-inspired cuisine with marina views.
Award-winning all-day island restaurant in the historic village, known for breakfast through dinner and outdoor seating.
Coffee-and-sweets stop with gift shop, serving espresso, ice cream, and light bites.
Inside 'Tween Waters
Tropical poolside bar at 'Tween Waters on Captiva. Light bites, cocktails, and cold drinks by the pool.
Inside 'Tween Waters
Elegant fine dining at 'Tween Waters Island Resort on Captiva. Known for fresh seafood, steaks, and an extensive wine list in a historic setting.
Inside South Seas
Market and counter dining with prepared breakfast and lunch foods. Open to the community; resort amenity access is separate.
Longtime Captiva village staple serving breakfast through dinner with seafood, island favorites, and live music daily.
Inside South Seas
Restricted access: eligible South Seas guests and owners with Club Captiva amenity access only; not general public dining. Fresh seafood and Southwest Florida favorites overlooking the Bayview pools at South Seas.
Inside South Seas
Restricted access: eligible South Seas guests and owners with Club Captiva amenity access only; not general public dining. Family-friendly South Seas spot for pizza, grinders, salads, and ice cream sundaes.
Inside South Seas
Coffee shop at The Shops at South Seas. Open to the community; resort amenity access is separate.
Intimate Captiva village spot pairing fresh seafood dishes with a curated wine selection in a cozy atmosphere.
Inside South Seas
Restricted access: dining for eligible South Seas guests and owners with Club Captiva amenity access, not general public dining. A resort bar with food service.
Captiva's most iconic restaurant since 1979, featuring three floors of vintage décor, American fare, and world-famous cakes.
Inside South Seas
Restricted access: dining for eligible South Seas guests and owners with Club Captiva amenity access, not general public dining. Breakfast and light bites at the resort clubhouse.
Popular waterfront restaurant with fresh seafood focus and one of Captiva's premier sunset dining experiences.
Public market on Andy Rosse Lane with deli selections and bakery items. A quick-bites stop rather than a table-service restaurant.
Iconic beachfront pub and Captiva institution, famous for sunset dining, live music, and a laid-back island atmosphere.
Inside 'Tween Waters
Casual waterfront restaurant at 'Tween Waters on Captiva. Fresh seafood and American favorites with marina views.
These beloved island spots did not reopen after Hurricane Ian (September 2022). They remain part of the islands' story.
A Sanibel staple for over 40 years, known for hot dogs, fish sandwiches, and old-school Florida charm.
Permanently closed. Formerly gulf-front dining at the Sundial Beach Resort & Spa.
An upscale supper club at The Dunes Golf & Tennis Club. Closed permanently — the location was sold.
A casual waterfront seafood spot that served some of the best fried clams and lobster rolls on the island.
A beloved Sanibel landmark known for its fun atmosphere and family-friendly dining. The go-to spot for burgers, seafood, and tropical drinks.